After
reading Shen and Rodriguez (and to a certain extent, Rose) it is clear as to where they stand
in the discovery of their voice and where they stand within the
academic discourse. However, what are women saying about finding
their written voice in academic circles, universities, and even in
high school? Flynn had barely skimmed the surface with a feminist
approach to the theory of composition. Yes, we had samples of male
and female writing that more or less supported her theory of rational
male thinkers and emotional female nurturers. Mellix does have a good
compromise between the language she learned at home and the language
she used at school from a very young age. It seems like she has to
flip back and forth depending on who she is speaking with, her
environment, or her mood. But she concludes that she is continually
finding new aspects of herself and that enables her to grow. But what
of inner-city girls that discovered a love of literature, or
disillusioned college students who switched to an English major,
simply more academic journal accounts of women who recount their
efforts of negotiating between what is real to them versus what has
been taught/ingrained into them by (male) composition.
Better
yet, what is a student’s take on how they write? We have been
discussing how the academics feel about the push and pull of academic
vs. authentic voice. But how has the student, male or female, found
what they feel is the most authentic form of writing to them?
No comments:
Post a Comment